A Silver lining

Census records are a treasure trove of information for genealogists and can produce a number of ‘yes!’ moments of discovery.

As census-taking improved and more information became available, the task of tracking a person or a family was also made much easier.

Back in 1841 only basic details were provided such as place of residence and for those aged 20 or older, their age was rounded up or down five years. So while you could be somewhat sure you had the right family in 1841 you had to compare it with the 1851 census to have it confirmed. Mostly that works out.

Click for larger view.

As way of illustration, the follow is a transcript from the 1841 census for a farm named Crossley about 12 miles from Aberdeen in Scotland. The John Silver aged 60 is one of my great-great-great grandfathers. If interested you can click on the image at right for larger view.

1841    Crossley, Fetteresso, Kincardine, Scotland

John Silver, aged 60, farmer

Helen Silver, aged 55

Alexander Silver, aged 30, agricultural labourer

Jean Silver, aged 25, female servant

John Silver, aged 15, agricultural labourer

Isobel Falconer, aged 13, female servant

Robert Thow, aged 12, agricultural labourer

Elizabeth Taylor, aged 11, female servant

So what we have could be seen as just a list of names with ages and occupations. The next person to focus on is Alexander Silver, aged 30, who is my great-great grandfather in this line.

Because the 1841 census does not state whether a person is married or single, we have to refer to the 1851 census record or investigate marriage records to discover that.

Other people on the record to look at are Isobel Falconer, aged 13, a servant on the farm along with Robert Thow, aged 12, and Elizabeth Taylor, aged 11.

On the same page of this census entry the Silver family have as neighbours the Thow family and the Taylor family, also part of Crossley farm. Other information I have tells me that the Silver family leased Crossley, so the two other families could be joint tenants. My guess is that Robert Thow and Elizabeth Taylor were children from the neighbouring families.

But what about Isobel Falconer, aged 13? Where was she from? On the 1851 census, we find Isobel Falconer, aged 23, single, at Stripeside of Crossley with her family. Given Crossley and Stripeside of Crossley are in the same parish, we can assume they may have been neighbouring properties although that is not yet confirmed.

So the Silver family and the Falconer family most certainly were known to one another. 

My Silver family is still at Crossley in 1851 where, by this time, my great-great grandfather Alexander Silver is aged 42 and still single. However in November 1851 Alexander did get married and this is a transcript of that parish record:

Maryculter marriages 1851: Silver and Falconer. Alexander Silver in this parish and Isobel Falconer in the parish of Feterresso were matrimonially contracted on the 28th November 1851 and after proclamation of banns were married on the 11th December 1851 by the Rev John Bowen, in presence of witnesses. 

Isobel Falconer who
married Alexander Silver.

So now I discover that the Alexander Silver and Isobel Falconer who married in 1851 were in the same household in 1841, he as the farmer’s son and she as a farm servant.

This is further confirmed by the 1861 census where we find Alex and Isobel and children at Burnside, most likely a neighbouring farm to Crossley. There are several farms named Burnside in Aberdeenshire but Burnside Farm, Maryculter, which is closer to the River Dee than other Burnsides is the likely place. And given that many of this Silver family were buried in Maryculter on the River Dee, it’s reasonable to assume that they lived close by.

1861 census for Burnside Farm, Maryculter:

Alexander SILVER, aged 51, farmer of 60 acres born Maryculter, Kincardineshire

Isabel SILVER wife, aged 32, born Strachan, Kincardine

Helen SILVER dau, aged 8, born Maryculter, Kincardineshire

John SILVER son, aged 5, born Maryculter, Kincardineshire

Alexander SILVER son, aged 2, born Maryculter, Kincardineshire

Isabel M SILVER dau, aged 10 Mo, born Maryculter, Kincardineshire

John Copland 14

Harriet Findlay 19

John Irmay 15

Then, 10 years later, the family is back at Crossley.

1871 census for Crossley, Fetteresso, Kincardine:

Alexander Silver head married, aged 61, farmer of 150 Acres 80 Arable Employs 2 Men 2 woman born Maryculter, Kincardine

Isabella Silver wife married, aged 44 years, born Strachan, Kincardine

Hellen Silver daughter unmarried, aged 18, farmer’s daughter Maryculter, Kincardine

John Silver son, aged 14, farmer’s son Maryculter, Kincardine

Alexander Silver son, aged 12, scholar Maryculter, Kincardine

Isabella M Silver daughter, aged 10, Maryculter, Kincardine

James Silver son, aged 7, Maryculter, Kincardine

Ann Fraser servant, aged 16, domestic servant Fetteresso, Kincardine

Robert McKilligan servant unmarried, aged 29, Nigg

William Duncan servant, aged 14, farm servant Glatt? Aberdeenshire

So the 1871 reveals their youngest child is James Silver, who is my great-grandfather.

Alexander SILVER   M, aged      71 M Maryculter, Kincardine, Scotland      Rel: Head   occ:  Farmer Of 120 Acres 80 Arable Employs 2 Men 2 Girls 1 Boy

lsabella SILVER  M, aged 53 F Strachan, Kincardine, Scotland          Rel:  Wife

Hellen SILVER    U, aged   28 F Maryculter, Kincardine, Scotland        Rel:  Daur

John SILVER      U, aged    25 M Maryculter, Kincardine, Scotland        Rel:  Son

Alexander SILVER U, aged  22 M Maryculter, Kincardine, Scotland        Rel:  Son

lsabella SILVER  U, aged   20 F Maryculter, Kincardine, Scotland        Rel:  Daur

John ROBERTSON   U, aged   14 M Banchory Devenick, Kincardine, Scotland Rel:  Servant

 

We then go on to the 1881 census (above) where we find most of the family still together but my great-grandfather is missing. However, he is not far away on Cockley farm where he is apprenticed as a carpenter. As the youngest James proved to be the ‘boldest’ in that he left for Australia sometime about 1890 and married in Brisbane in 1892 to Janet Todd who hails from Kirkbrightshire, more than 200 miles by road from Aberdeen.

So, how did they meet? There is confusion over exactly where but Janet was in service somewhere in Scotland because she spoke about it to her grandchildren.

We can only assume that James Silver moved away from Aberdeenshire to find work as a carpenter and met Janet at some point because it is clear they both arranged to travel separately to Australia where they eventually married and had six children, five of whom survived to adulthood. Their eldest, Margaret Isabella, was my mum’s mum.

So about 11 decades after a teenager named Isobel Falconer met and later married Alexander Silver, I came into the world and a series of circumstances led to my existence. In other reminder of the closeness of the family connections in that area, Isobel Falconer's sister, Mary Ann married Alexander Silver's first cousin James Silver, who also happened to be his second cousin.

This is where things getting really complicated but, of course, we genealogists love such discoveries. The Silver boys were maternal first cousins as their mothers were sisters and they were second cousins because their paternal grandfathers were brothers. Whew!

So, a few names and ages on a page soon becomes a family story. It’s a story that’s been repeated millions of times and underscores just how fortunate we all are to have a life.

Live it well … and do some genealogy to … there are rewards to be had.

Comments powered by CComment

Alexander Silver (1809-1882)

Alexander Silver and Isobel Falconer Silver family members: At left is Isobel Falconer who married Alexander Silver with her three sons Alex…

Alexander Silver (1858-1907)

Alexander (Sandy) Silver (1858-1907) with his wife Helen Jane Watt and the three children who survived to adulthood. Top right is Alexander (Sandy)…

Gertrude Duncan, the publican's daughter who became a hospital administrator

The Red Lion Inn at Uckfield, Sussex in 1915. Image taken by visiting Scottish cousins. Gertrude Duncan, the publican's daughter who became a…

Harvieston fire

Two articles about the Harvieston Farm fire Dundee Courier 31 January 1902, PAGE 4. DESTRUCTIVE FARM FIRE IN THE MEARNS FOURTH WITHIN A FORTNIGHT…

Helen Silver

Helen Silver (1852 - 1915) married Alexander Duncan and moved to England where they are found on a farm at Byfleet in Surrey in 1891. Given they had…

Isobel Menzies Silver

Isobel Menzies Silver (1860-1934) lived with her brothers at Harvieston Farm before getting married later in life (aged 46) to a widower named John…

James Silver

James Silver came to Australia in 1892 where he was later joined by his fiancee Janet Todd. They married in Brisbane, Queensland, before moving more…

John Silver of Harvieston farm

By Aberdeenshire Silver descendant Warren Nunn John Silver is a bit of mystery man. An older, unmarried brother of my great grandfather James Silver,…

Picture comparison

I have images from Scotland from various sources that connect to the Silvers of Kincardineshire. My line connects through Alexander Silver who…

Pocket watch mystery

Piecing together this timepiece's journey The pocket watch in which is inscribed the name "Geo. Donald". The watch is being held by James Silver's…

Silver newspaper research

What follows is drawn from Aberdeenshire newspapers and relates to the Silver surname. Aberdeen Evening Express 24 September 1960, p7: SILVER.-At…

Silvers in Australia

When a young Scottish carpenter named James Silver arrived in Queensland in 1892, he was about to begin life in a country that was considerably…

The life of Reverend Alexander Silver of Dunnottar

By Aberdeenshire Silver descendant Warren Nunn Reverend Alexander Silver was for about 40 years the spiritual leader of Dunnottar church near…